Copyright ©ERS Journals Ltd 2005 Oral L-arginine supplementation in cystic fibrosis patients: a placebo-controlled study1 Children's Hospital, 2 Dept of Human Genetics, 3 Dept of Pharmacy, University of Duisburg-Essen, Essen, Germany CORRESPONDENCE: H. Grasemann, Children's Hospital, University of Essen, Hufeland Str. 55, D-45122 Essen, Germany. Fax: 49 2017235983. E-mail: hartmutg@hotmail.com Keywords: Cystic fibrosis, L-arginine, lung function, nitric oxide
Received: July 21, 2004
Exhaled nitric oxide (eNO) is decreased in cystic fibrosis (CF). The effect of oral L-arginine, the precursor of enzymatic nitric oxide (NO) formation, on airway NO in patients with CF was studied. In a pilot study, oral L-arginine was given in a single dose of 200 mg·kg1 body weight to eight healthy controls and eight CF patients. Subsequently, the same L-arginine dose was given to 10 patients with CF (five females) t.i.d. for 6 weeks in a randomised double-blind placebo-controlled crossover study. A single dose of oral L-arginine resulted in a 5.5-fold increase of L-arginine in plasma and a 1.3-fold increase of L-arginine in sputum after 2 h. Maximum eNO, within 3 h of L-arginine intake, increased significantly in both CF patients (5.4±2.1 ppb versus 8.3±3.5 ppb) and controls (18.0±8.1 ppb versus 26.4±12.3 ppb). Supplementation of L-arginine for 6 weeks resulted in a sustained increase in eNO compared to placebo (9.7±5.7 ppb versus 6.3±3.1 ppb). An effect of L-arginine supplementation on forced expiratory volume in one second was not observed. These data indicate that airway nitric oxide formation in cystic fibrosis patients can be augmented with oral L-arginine supplementation. The amino acid L-arginine is the precursor for enzymatic nitric oxide (NO) synthesis. NO synthases (NOSs) have been shown to be involved in regulatory processes in the lung including inflammation, host defense and bronchomotor control. The fraction of exhaled NO (eNO) has been found to be reduced in patients with cystic fibrosis (CF) compared to healthy individuals 1. The mechanisms that lead to low airway NO in CF are not completely understood but may include mechanical retention of NO in airway secretions, conversion of NO to metabolites, and consumption of NO by denitrifying bacteria 2. Whilst limited evidence would support all of these concepts, there is also evidence for reduced enzymatic formation of NO in CF, whereby blood or tissue levels of L-arginine may become rate limiting for NO synthesis 3, 4. The bronchodilatatory effect of NO (in ppm concentrations) is well known 57, and recent research in animals suggests a causal relationship between airway NOS activity and bronchomotor tone in CF. In these experiments, the addition of L-arginine resulted in a significant increase of electrical field stimulated relaxation of isolated tracheas from mice deficient for the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) protein but not from wild-type animals 8. In cross-sectional studies in CF patients, a positive correlation was observed between pulmonary function and both eNO 1, 9, 10 and NO metabolite concentration in sputum 11, suggesting that pulmonary function is reduced in CF patients with decreased airway NO formation. This view is supported by the recent observation that variants in the neuronal NOS gene (NOS1), that are associated with low eNO, seem to predispose to a more rapid decline in pulmonary function in children with CF 12. In previous studies, the current authors demonstrated that neither inhalation of NO-containing gas nor infusion of L-arginine had an effect on pulmonary function in CF patients. However, a single dose of i.v. L-arginine in a dose of 500 mg·kg1 body weight resulted in a significant increase of eNO in these patients 13, 14. Oral L-arginine in doses of 100 mg·kg1 and 200 mg·kg1 body weight had been shown to increase eNO in healthy human subjects 15. The effect of oral L-arginine supplementation in CF patients has, to the present authors' knowledge, not been studied. The current authors speculated that augmentation of airway NO formation by oral supplementation of L-arginine could have a positive effect on airway NO formation and pulmonary function in these patients. Therefore, the present authors studied the effect of a single dose of oral L-arginine on eNO and a 6-week supplementation of oral L-arginine in a dose of 200 mg·kg1 body weight t.i.d. on eNO and pulmonary function in patients with CF in a randomised double-blind placebo-controlled study.
The diagnosis of CF in participating patients had been confirmed by repeated sweat tests with chloride concentrations >60 mmol·L1, and by mutation analysis of the CFTR gene. Written informed consent was obtained from each patient, and/or their parents, respectively. The study was approved by the institutional review board of the University of Essen, Essen, Germany.
Single dose experiments
Study design Measurements of nasal NO, eNO and blood sampling were performed at baseline as well as 60, 120 and 180 min following the intake of L-arginine. Blood was collected in EDTA containing 2.7 mL tubes by venipuncture for the measurement of plasma amino acid and urea concentrations in all subjects. Spontaneously expectorated sputum was collected before and 120 min after L-arginine intake in all but two patients, who were unable to expectorate sputum.
Double-blind placebo-controlled trial
Study design
Pulmonary function measurements
Nitric oxide measurements
Plasma amino acids
Statistical analysis
Single L-arginine dose Baseline plasma concentrations of the amino acids L-arginine, citrulline, and ornithine, and plasma urea did not differ between CF patients and controls. A single dose of oral L-arginine (200 mg·kg1 body weight) resulted in a significant increase of plasma L-arginine concentrations in both CF patients and healthy controls. Plasma levels of citrulline, the product of L-arginine conversion by NO synthases, did not increase after oral L-arginine. Plasma levels of ornithine and urea, which are products of L-arginine metabolism by arginases, increased significantly in CF. A significant increase in plasma ornithine but not urea was seen in the controls (table 1
Mean eNO at baseline was 15.0±8.1 ppb in controls and 5.4±2.1 ppb in CF patients (p = 0.006), confirming previous findings of decreased airway NO formation in CF. Similarly, nasal NO at baseline was significantly lower in CF patients than in controls (62.4±39.7 ppb versus 158.6±43.4 ppb, p<0.001). A single dose of L-arginine resulted in a significant increase in eNO after 1, 2, and 3 h in the controls (p<0.01, respectively). In the CF patients there was considerable variability in the course of eNO after oral L-arginine. Mean eNO at the given time-points did not increase significantly (6.5±2.2 ppb, p = 0.06 at 1 h; table 2
Mean nasal NO concentrations did not change significantly after a single dose of L-arginine in controls and CF patients at the given time-points, but the maximal±SD increase of nasal NO was 1.3±0.5 fold (p = 0.03) in controls and 1.2±0.2 fold (p = 0.08) in CF (table 2
Double-blind placebo-controlled trial L-arginine was well tolerated in all patients but one, who acquired airway infection with Burkholderia cepacia, which was successfully eradicated with i.v. antibiotic treatment. This patient was excluded from the final analysis. Of the 10 patients who finished the study, five took L-arginine for 6 weeks followed by 6 weeks of placebo and five started with placebo followed by L-arginine supplementation.
Mean eNO at baseline (after 14 days of i.v. antibiotics) was 11.4±6.0 ppb. After 6 weeks of L-arginine eNO was 9.7±5.7 ppb, which was not significantly different from baseline. After 6 weeks of placebo eNO declined to 6.3±3.1 ppb which was significantly lower than eNO at baseline (p = 0.001) and after L-arginine supplementation (p = 0.03; fig. 6
The decline of FEV1 from baseline (58.8±33.1% predicted) was similar after L-arginine treatment (54.5±32.9% predicted, p = 0.04) and placebo (53.4±31.8% predicted, p = 0.01). Quantitative sputum counts in eight CF patients were not different after 6 weeks of L-arginine or placebo (data not shown).
The present study confirmed that airway NO levels are decreased in CF patients compared to healthy controls. Oral L-arginine given in a single dose of 200 mg·kg1 body weight resulted in a small but statistically significant increase of lower airway NO formation in patients with CF. This increase in eNO was smaller in CF than in healthy controls treated with the same dose of L-arginine, although the increase in L-arginine plasma levels after application was not reduced in CF patients. The current authors further demonstrated that oral L-arginine given in the same dose t.i.d. for 6 weeks had a sustained effect on eNO in CF patients, preventing the decline of eNO from baseline values obtained after i.v. antibiotic treatment. It is now widely accepted that NO formation in the upper and lower airways is decreased in CF 1, 2, 21, 22, and the results from the present study confirm these findings. The reasons for decreased NO formation in CF are not completely understood, but studies in mouse models and in patients with CF have found that the expression of the inducible isoform of NO synthases (NOS2) is decreased or absent in CF airways 3, 4, 22. Recent evidence suggests that this decrease in NOS2 expression parallels the neutrophil dominated airway inflammation in CF. Wooldridge et al. 22 have studied NOS2 expression by immunohistochemistry and found decreasing expression of NOS2 with increasing concentrations of inflammatory markers, such as interleukin-8 and the number of neutrophils in CF BAL fluid in different cell types from the airways. This effect of inflammation on NOS2 expression is in contrast to other inflammatory airway conditions, such as asthma, but could explain the interesting observation that eNO in CF patients increases when treated with antibiotics although a reduction of denitrifying organisms in the CF airways may also contribute to the increase in eNO during antibiotic treatment 23, 24. In accordance with this observation, eNO in the CF patients participating in the present study was significantly lower after 6 weeks of placebo, compared to baseline values after 2 weeks of i.v. antibiotic treatment. Of interest, 6 weeks of oral L-arginine resulted in a significantly higher eNO than treatment with placebo, and was not different from the eNO after i.v. antibiotic treatment, thus the expected decrease of eNO after discontinuation of antibiotic treatment could sufficiently be prevented by L-arginine supplementation. It is important to mention here, that eNO in the current study was measured 12 h after the last intake of L-arginine, suggesting a sustained effect of long-term supplementation of L-arginine on airway NO formation. The single dose experiments showed that the increase in plasma L-arginine was only transient since plasma levels peaked after 2 h and had already returned to baseline after 3 h. However, the increased eNO after 6 weeks of L-arginine supplementation was measured 12 h after the last L-arginine intake. Possible explanations for this sustained effect are that L-arginine supplementation may have resulted in accumulation of L-arginine or of nitrogen oxides stored in airway secretions and thus in either a longer lasting substrate availability for NO synthesis from NOS or lasting NO formation from nitrogen oxides. Another explanation for the observed sustained increase in eNO is that the 6 week L-arginine supplementation may have resulted in an increase of NOS expression in CF airways. Indeed, an increase in L-arginine concentration may augment NO formation from NOS by two independent mechanisms. One mechanism can be simply explained by increased L-arginine conversion in the setting of increased substrate availability. The other is an effect of extracellular L-arginine levels on cellular expression of NOS. This effect has recently been observed in in vitro experiments with stimulated astrocytes in cell culture. In these experiments adding increasing doses of L-arginine to the culture supernatant resulted in a dose dependent increase of NOS2 expression 25. Taking into account the above mentioned effect of extracellular L-arginine concentration on NOS2 expression, it is quite conceivable that low airway NO formation in CF results from reduced bioavailability of L-arginine, the precursor of enzymatic NO formation from NOS. No differences were found in plasma L-arginine concentrations between clinically stable CF patients and healthy controls at baseline, which confirmed previous findings 14, 22. The larger increase in ornithine concentration in plasma at 2 h after a single dose of L-arginine in CF patients compared to controls (p = 0.05) could result from the fact that peak L-arginine levels at that time were also higher than in controls. Alternatively, this finding may suggest that the activity of arginases is increased in CF. Arginases are enzymes that metabolise L-arginine to form ornithine and urea. The expression of arginases seems to be increased in inflammatory airway conditions such as asthma 26, 27. Arginases and NOS compete for their common substrate L-arginine, and a shift of balance towards the expression of arginases, for instance during phases of infection or increased inflammation, could reduce the bioavailability of L-arginine for NOS and thus result in a down-regulation of NOS2 expression. However, NOS2 expression or arginase activity was not measured in this study. Further studies are needed to elucidate the role of arginases for L-arginine homeostasis in CF. NOS is involved in a variety of processes in the lung including regulation of vascular muscle tone, bronchomotor control, host defense and inflammation 5, 28. Low airway NO formation in CF beneficially effects the colonisation of CF airways with certain pathogens, as suggested by the observation that certain variants in the genes encoding for the constitutive NOS isoforms NOS1 and NOS3 are associated with lower eNO and an increased rate of P. aeruginosa colonisation in CF 29, 30. The role of NO in the defense against Pseudomonas has also been demonstrated in in vitro experiments in which the NO donor, sodium nitroprusside, induced a dose dependent killing of P. aeruginosa 3. However, these experiments were performed with a cultured Pseudomonas strain, and it is unclear whether increased NO formation in CF airways would also have a measurable effect on Pseudomonas growth in chronically infected airways. In contrast, L-arginine may have a positive effect on Pseudomonas growth since Pseudomonas uses L-arginine as a substrate. In the current study, differences were not seen in quantitative P. aeruginosa sputum counts between 6 weeks of L-arginine supplementation and placebo. Decreased NO formation may also have a negative effect on CF pulmonary function independent of airway colonisation. In experiments with mice it was shown, that the addition of L-arginine resulted in a significant increase of isolated trachea relaxation from mice deficient for the CFTR protein but not from wild-type animals 8. In humans, a positive correlation was observed between pulmonary function and both eNO 1, 9, 10 and NO metabolite concentrations in sputum 11, suggesting that pulmonary function is better in CF patients with higher airway NO formation. In addition, variants in the neuronal NOS gene (NOS1) associated with low eNO seem to predispose to a more rapid decline in pulmonary function in children with CF 12. These data suggest that NO deficiency may, at least in part, contribute to airway obstruction in CF and that augmentation of NO synthesis could have a beneficial effect on pulmonary function in these patients. However, the present authors did not observe a positive effect of oral L-arginine supplementation on pulmonary function, measured by spirometry, despite the positive effect on eNO, supporting previous papers showing that concentrations of NO in the low ppb range are not relevant to lung function in CF 13, 14. This lack of effect may, at least in part, also be related to the relatively small study population and to study design. The time point of the initiation of L-arginine supplementation may be critical since its effects may differ if started directly after i.v. treatment as compared to a later time point, when infection and inflammation are not suppressed by antibiotic treatment and airway NO formation may be further down-regulated. In the single dose experiments, maximum nasal nitric oxide increased significantly in controls and a similar tendency was also observed in cystic fibrosis patients. The increase in nasal nitric oxide was less pronounced than seen in a previous study by the current authors using 500 mg·kg1 body weight L-arginine i.v., which is probably related to the lower dose used in the present study 14. The major source of nitric oxide in the upper airway is the paranasal sinuses where the highest concentrations of nitric oxide have been measured 31. In cystic fibrosis, mucous obstruction results in poor communication of the paranasal sinuses with the nasal cavity and increases in nitric oxide production in the sinuses may not be detected by nasal nitric oxide measurements in these patients.
The authors would like to thank the patients for their participation, as well as M. Groch and B. Cirkel for technical assistance.
This article has been cited by other articles:
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||