Copyright ©ERS Journals Ltd 2004 Penetration of newer quinolones in the empyema fluid1 2nd Dept of Surgery and 2 Pneumonology, Medical School, Democritus University of Thrace, Alexandroupolis, and 3 Center of Toxicological Science and Research, Dept of Medicine, University of Crete, Heraklion, Greece. 4 Pulmonary Dept, Saint Thomas Hospital and Vanderbilt University, Nashville, TN, USA CORRESPONDENCE: D.E. Bouros, Medical School, University of Thrace, Head, Dept of Pneumonology, University Hospital, Alexandroupolis 68100, Greece. Fax: 30 2551076106. E-mail: bouros@med.duth.gr Keywords: Chromatography, Escherichia coli, levofloxacin, moxifloxacin, plural empyema, turpentine
Received: March 4, 2004
This study was supported by a grant from Abbott Laboratories (Hellas) and ELPEN SA Pharmaceuticals.
The degree of penetration of newer quinolones into the pleural fluid has not been studied. The objective of the present study was to determine the degree to which moxifloxacin and levofloxacin penetrate into empyemic pleural fluid using a new rabbit model of empyema. An empyema was created via the intrapleural injection of turpentine (1 mL), followed 24 h later by instillation of 2 mL (1x1010) Escherichia coli bacteria (ATCC 35218) into the pleural space of New Zealand white rabbits. After an empyema was verified by thoracentesis and pleural fluid analysis, moxifloxacin and levofloxacin (25 mg·kg1 for both, i.v.) were administered. Antibiotic levels were determined in samples of pleural fluid and in blood collected serially over 12 h. Antibiotic levels were measured using HPLC. Each of the antibiotics penetrated well into the empyemic pleural fluid. Antibiotic penetration was the greatest for moxifloxacin (area under the curve (AUC) for pleural fluid/blood (AUCPF/AUCblood) ratio=1.37) followed by levofloxacin (ratio=1.13). The time to equilibration between the pleural fluid and blood antibiotic levels was more rapid for moxifloxacin (3.9 h) than for levofloxacin (4.4 h). With moxifloxacin, the peak pleural fluid concentration (Cmax,PF) was 2.77 µg·mL1 and occurred at a time to maximum pleural fluid concentration (Tmax,PF) of 6 h after infusion and decreased thereafter. The peak blood concentration (Cmax,blood) was 4.81 µg·mL1 at 1 h after administration. With levofloxacin, the peak pleural fluid level (Cmax,PF=1.39 µg·mL1) occurred at 6 h (Tmax,PF=6 h) after infusion. The Cmax,blood was 1.88 µg·mL1 at 1 h after administration. In conclusion, differences were found in the degree of penetration of the two quinolones into infected pleural fluid in rabbits. The clinical significance of these differences is unknown. More studies are needed to evaluate the pharmacokinetic parameters in the pleural space in humans. Bacterial pneumonia has an associated parapneumonic pleural effusion in 40% of cases 1. A small percentage of these parapneumonic effusions evolve into complicated parapneumonic effusions and empyema 2, 3. Thoracic empyema continues to remain a significant medical problem. There are several therapeutic options available and the choice of therapy is usually dictated by the severity of the disease on presentation. The usual initial treatment remains parenteral antibiotics with chest tube placement 4, 5. Although numerous antibiotics are used for the treatment of pneumonia with parapneumonic effusion, little has been published on the pharmacokinetics of parenterally administered antibiotics in the pleural fluid. Advanced-generation fluoroquinolone agents offer excellent activity against both Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacilli. Fluoroquinolones variably offer greater efficacy with highly resistant pneumococcii, and/or greater anaerobic coverage, providing advantages for treating selected patients when used as monotherapy. Some medical systems have adopted fluoroquinolones as empirical therapy in clinical pathways for the treatment of community-acquired pneumonia 6, 7. The quinolones are derivatives of nalidixic acid and exhibit favourable-pharmacokinetic properties. Thus, the new quinolones, such as levofloxacin and moxifloxacin show promise for treatment of a variety of bacterial infections 8, 9. The most frequent microbes in pleural empyema are anaerobic bacteria, Streptococcus pneumoniae, group A ß-haemolytic streptococci and Staphylococcus aureus 10, 11. Importantly, empirical therapy needs to be initiated as soon as pleural fluid, sputum and blood samples have been taken. Second and third generation cephalosporins, ß-lactam-ß-lactamase inhibitor combinations, macrolides, fluoroquinolones, metronidazole, clindamycin, imipenem, aminoglycosides or aztreonam may be considered 12. In addition to the specificity of the antimicrobial agent for the offending microorganism, its distribution within the body is a critical factor in determining its therapeutic efficacy. If the antimicrobial agent does not enter the site at which the offending microorganism resides, bacterial growth will continue despite in vitro susceptibility of the organism to the drug. The utility of an antimicrobial agent in the treatment of pleural diseases depends on the attainment of adequate drug concentrations within intrapleural sites of infection 12. Infact, specific to the treatment of pleural infections, it is important to obtain sufficient levels of the antibiotics in the pleural fluid. For various reasons, such as limited permeability of thickened pleura, pleural fluid antibiotic levels obtained after systemic administration could be different compared with serum levels. However, there have been only limited studies on the relationship between serum and pleural fluid antibiotic levels. Most studies in humans have involved patients with diseases other than empyema. The physiology is likely to be different with empyema, since empyema fluid is more acidic and the pleural surfaces are thicker 13. Correlations between the pleural fluid and serum antibiotic levels have not been studied in detail in animals. Teixeira et al. 14, in an elegant study using a new rabbit model of empyema, determined the relationships between the pleural fluid and serum antibiotic levels of metronidazole, penicillin, clindamycin, ceftriaxone, vancomycin and gentamicin. The pharmacokinetics were studied after i.v. administration. It was found that the penetration of these antibiotics into the infected pleural fluid, and the equilibration between the serum and pleural fluid varied from one antibiotic to the next. The purpose of the present study was to determine the pharmacokinetic parameters of moxifloxacin and levofloxacin in the blood and pleural fluid in an experimental rabbit model of empyema, after i.v. administration. It was hypothesised that both moxifloxacin and levofloxacin would penetrate well into the pleural fluid and achieve therapeutic levels in the pleural fluid of rabbits with empyema.
Animals A total of 10 male New Zealand white rabbits (4.05.0 kg) were used for the study. The animals were housed in individual cages and allowed food and water ad libitum. Three rabbits each were used to study the pleural fluid antibiotic levels after i.v. administration of the antibiotics moxifloxacin and levofloxacin. This project was conducted in the Experimental Surgery Dept, Medical School, University of Thrace, Alexandroupolis, Greece, and was supervised by the University's veterinarian. The study protocol was approved by the Veterinary Administration Medical Centre, Alexandroupolis, Greece.
Bacteria preparation
Empyema induction Turpentine (1 mL) 16 (Riedel de Haen; Sigma-Aldrich Laborchemikalien, GMBH, Seelze Germany) was administered into the pleural space of the animals and the chest tube was then flushed with 1.5 mL of saline solution. Escherichia coli (1x1010 in a final volume of 2 mL saline) was injected 24 h later through the cannula into the pleural cavity of the animals.
Empyema verification
Antibiotic administration
Pleural fluid and blood specimens
Measurement of antibiotic levels
Preparation of standard curves
Quantification of biological extracts
Apparatus
Extraction procedure for HPLC analysis
Necropsy of the rabbits
Statistical analysis
All rabbits developed empyema after intrapleural injection of turpentine and 1x1010 Escherichia coli (table 1
The relationships between the pleural fluid antibiotic levels and the blood antibiotic levels varied from one antibiotic to the other (fig. 1
The time to equilibration of the pleural fluid antibiotic level and the blood antibiotic level was more rapid for moxifloxacin (3.9 h) than for levofloxacin (4.4 h). With moxifloxacin, the peak pleural fluid antibiotic level occurred 6 h after infusion and decreased slowly thereafter. The pleural fluid level exceeded the blood level after the 3.9-h time point and was several times higher than the blood level at 6 and 12 h. With levofloxacin, the peak pleural fluid antibiotic level occurred 6 h after infusion. After the 6-h time point, it decreased slightly until the 12-h time point. The pleural fluid level exceeded the blood level 4.4 h after infusion and was higher than the blood level at 6 and 12 h.
The pharmacokinetic data for the two different antibiotics are compared in table 2
Pathological studies
The present study, using an experimental model of empyema in the rabbit, shows that the penetration of moxifloxacin and levofloxacin into infected pleural fluid varies from one antibiotic to another. Besides the AUCPF/blood ratio, the area under the inhibitory curve allows agents with long half-lives, like fluoroquinolones, to be compared with each other 23, 24. For the most frequent microbes in pleural empyema, such as H. influenza, E. coli, Klebsiella spp., S. aureus and S. pneumoniae, a MIC of 0.030.25 µg·mL1 (moxifloxacin) or a MIC of 0.031 µg·mL1 (levofloxacin) is required 6, and the ratio AUC/MIC permits the studied quinolones to be contrasted. Strahilevitz et al. 22, studied the effect of moxifloxacin in an experimental pneumococcal pleural empyema model in rabbits. They reported that the AUC for moxifloxacin in the empyema fluid over 12 h was 34.3 mg·h1·L1, while the AUC in the present study was 22.9 µg·h1·mL1. In the study byStrahilevitz et al. 22, the AUC in the blood was 29.4 mg·h1·L1, while in the current study it was 16.7 µg·h1·mL1. The reason that the AUC in the blood was higher in the study by Strahilevitz et al. 22 is unclear, but this higher value for the AUC in the blood is the probable explanation for the lower AUC in the empyema fluid in the present study. The AUCPF/blood ratio was 1.37 for moxifloxacin and 1.13 for levofloxacin, and the time to equilibration of the pleural fluid antibiotic level and the blood antibiotic level occurred faster with moxifloxacin (3.9 h) than with levofloxacin (4.4 h). In a previous study 14, the AUCPF/serum ratios were 0.98 for metronidazole, 2.31 for penicillin, 0.74 for clindamycin, 0.82 for ceftriaxone, 0.61 for vancomycin and 0.49 for gentamycin. In the same study 14, the time to equilibration was 2 h for metronidazole, 1 h for penicillin, 4.5 h for clindamycin, 4 h for ceftriaxone, 4 h for vancomycin and 3.5 h for gentamycin. The comparison to the above values demonstrates that the newer quinolones penetrate empyemic pleural fluid in a comparable manner to the older antibiotics. Significant levels of moxifloxacin and levofloxacin remained in the pleural space for up to 12 h, despite diminishing blood antibiotic levels over time. In previous studies, Strahilevitz et al. 22 reported similar findings with moxifloxacin, while Teixeira et al. 14 only measured levels up to 6 h. However, they reported that levels of ceftriaxone were undetectable in the pleural fluid after 4 h 14.
Some previous studies have suggested that there is very little difference amongst antibiotics concerning their level of penetration into the pleural fluid. Taryle et al. 25 studied 16 patients (including five with empyema), and concluded that antibiotic concentrations were usually Sakuma et al. 27 studied the penetration of intravenous antibiotics from the lung into the pleural space after pulmonary resection and concluded that higher doses of antibiotics are required in patients with empyema after pneumonectomy. The findings of sustained elevated pleural fluid levels of moxifloxacin and levofloxacin in the current study were similar with that found for penicillin by Teixeira et al. 14. The pleural fluid antibiotic level remained >1 µg·mL1 at 12 h after infusion, while the simultaneously obtained blood levels had diminished to lower levels. The reason for this is unclear. Perhaps the answer relates to the relationship between fluoroquinolones, and the increased permeability of the pleural space with inflammation or the increased acidity of pleural fluid with empyema. It may be advantageous to use quinolones for susceptible organisms in patients with empyema, due to their prolonged elevated levels in infected pleural fluid in this experimental model of empyema. The equilibration between an antibiotic in the serum and the pleural fluid depends on several factors. These include the size of the pleural effusion (equilibration will occur less rapidly with larger pleural effusions), the thickness of the pleura (equilibration will occur less rapidly with a thicker pleura), the degree of pleural inflammation (equilibration willoccur more rapidly with inflammation due to increased protein flux) and the antibiotic itself. In the present study, all of the above factors were maintained constant, with the only variable being the antibiotic. There are certain limitations to the present study. It is not clear if these results obtained in the rabbit can be extrapolated to human, as rabbits are a species with thin visceral pleura, while humans have thick visceral pleura 28. It is likely that the equilibration of antibiotics would be more rapid in species with thin pleura. Infusion of an antibiotic over a 3-min period is not a typical method for administration of these antibiotics in humans. This infusion method may have also led to changes in the equilibration curves, which would be different if a longer infusion time had been used. In the current study, antibiotic treatment was initiated relatively early in the course of empyema, 24 h after bacterial challenge. The equilibration might have been longer if the empyema had been present for several days. The repeated pleural fluid aspirations carried out in the present investigation could possibly be regarded as a partial pleural empyema drainage, facilitating recovery. However, it resembles more closely the current clinical approach to pleural empyema. The present authors conclude that, in this rabbit model of empyema, there are differences in the degree of penetration into infected pleural fluid and in the equilibration time between serum and pleural fluid for the two quinolones. The clinical significance of these differences in humans is unknown, since there is not sufficient data concerning the penetration of these antimicrobial agents in the infected pleura in humans. More studies are needed to evaluate the pharmacokinetic parameters in the pleural space.
This article has been cited by other articles:
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||