Copyright ©ERS Journals Ltd 2003 Pulmonary perfusion quantified by electron-beam computed tomography: effects of hypoxia and inhaled NO1 Unit of Critical Care and 2 Dept of Imaging, National Heart and Lung Institute, Imperial College of Science, Technology and Medicine, Royal Brompton Hospital, London, UK CORRESPONDENCE: T.W. Evans, Royal Brompton Hospital, Sydney St, London, SW3 6NP. Fax: 44 171358524. E-mail: t.evans@rbh.nthames.nhs.uk Keywords: computed tomography, hypoxia, pulmonary perfusion
Received: September 13, 2002
A.T. Jones was supported by a Smith and Nephew Fellowship Work supported in part by the British Lung Foundation.
Patients with acute lung injury may benefit from the manipulation of pulmonary blood flow using inhaled nitric oxide (iNO) to optimise ventilation/perfusion matching. Current techniques for studying changes in regional pulmonary perfusion are difficult to apply clinically. This study therefore investigated the potential of electron-beam computed tomography (EBCT) to quantify the effects of hypoxia and iNO on regional pulmonary perfusion in five healthy subjects. Contrast-enhanced sections were obtained sequentially under conditions of normoxia, hypoxia (fractional concentration of oxygen in inspired gas (FI,O2) 0.12) and hypoxia, with iNO (14.8 parts per million (ppm)) administered during inspiration in the supine position. Regions of interest were placed along the nondependent to dependent axis and values for relative perfusion derived. Under normoxic conditions a vertical gradient of perfusion existed, which became less apparent due to increased perfusion in nondependent regions after the induction of hypoxia (FI,O2 0.12). The addition of iNO (FI,O2 0.12 and NO 14.8 ppm) increased perfusion in all regions of the lung section, suggesting redistribution of pulmonary perfusion from other regions of the lung. Absolute values of perfusion were comparable to those documented with existing techniques. The use of a high spatial-resolution technique confirmed the presence of marked perfusion heterogeneity between anatomically close regions of lung. Under physiological circumstances, the distribution of pulmonary blood flow is regulated by a local action of alveolar oxygen tension on precapillary pulmonary vessels. Thus, the reflex of hypoxic pulmonary vasoconstriction (HPV) ensures that blood flow is diverted away from areas of damaged lung, thereby preserving the matching of ventilation (V') and perfusion (Q') 1, 2. In contrast, patients with acute lung injury (ALI) demonstrate diminished HPV leading to adverse changes in V'/Q' matching, manifesting clinically as refractory hypoxaemia 3. The favourable manipulation of V'/Q' therefore assumes considerable therapeutic significance. In this context, nitric oxide (NO), an endothelially derived vasodilator that modulates vascular tone in health and disease 4, has been demonstrated to be a selective pulmonary vasodilator when administered by inhalation both in experimental animals 5, 6 and humans 7, improving physiological variables (specifically pulmonary artery pressure (Ppa) and arterial oxygen tension) in patients with ALI 4. The effects of NO on HPV in terms of the modulation of changes in regional pulmonary blood flow induced by hypoxaemia are, however, unknown. Although techniques for studying regional pulmonary perfusion have been difficult to apply clinically, a gravitational distribution of pulmonary perfusion has been described in normal subjects, determined by the interrelationship between hydrostatic, alveolar and interstitial pressures 8, 9. Moreover, animal studies employing high spatial-resolution techniques suggest that the influence of gravity is less important than the structure of the pulmonary vascular tree in determining regional blood flow in the lung 10, 11. The authors have recently employed electron-beam computed tomography (EBCT) to quantify regional pulmonary perfusion in normal subjects placed in the supine and prone positions, demonstrating that a gravitational gradient of pulmonary perfusion existed in both supine and prone positions 12. The aims of the current study, in normal subjects using EBCT, were therefore three-fold. First, changes in the regional distribution of pulmonary perfusion induced by hypoxaemia were explored. Secondly, the effects of inhaled NO (iNO) on modulating regional pulmonary blood flow under hypoxic conditions were evaluated. Thirdly, the effects of spatial resolution on the apparent distribution of pulmonary perfusion in adult human subjects were further investigated.
The experimental protocol, to which all subjects provided written, informed consent, was approved by the Ethics Committee of the Royal Brompton Hospital and was designed to minimise radiation exposure. The effective dose for each subject was 3.3 mSv, 33% of the effective radiation dose of a conventional contiguous computer tomography (CT) of the thorax, or equivalent to 1.5 yrs of background radiation. In all studies, subjects were placed in the supine position within the CT scanner (Imatron C150L; Imatron Inc., San Francisco, CA, USA). Following a separate period of training, all subjects were established on intermittent positive pressure ventilation (IPPV) administered via a mouthpiece (Evita II; Drager, Lubeck, Germany), using a tidal volume (VT) of 810 mL·kg1. IPPV was used throughout the study in order to first provide a closed system whereby inspired oxygen concentration and iNO concentration could be effectively controlled and any adverse atmospheric pollution avoided. Secondly, CT scans were performed during an inspiratory breath-hold manoeuvre (ventilator mediated) in an effort to standardise scanning conditions. Thirdly, the authors wished to standardise the experimental conditions to those used successfully in earlier studies using this technique 12.
Computed tomography scanning protocol
Administration of hypoxic gas mixture and inhaled nitric oxide
NO was administered using a simple constant flow system delivering 1% NO in N2 (BOC Special Gases, Guildford, UK) into the inspiratory limb of the ventilator circuit (Evita II; Draeger, Lubeck, Germany), via a low-flow meter (Ohmeda, Hatfield, UK). The concentration of NO and nitrogen dioxide (NO2) in the circuit was measured using a fuel-cell analyser (Micro Medicals, Rochester, UK) with a long response time (
Experimental protocol
Calculation of perfusion using electron-beam computed tomography
Pul is the peak Hounsfield Unit (HU) change due to contrast material and CDAdt is the area under the time density curve for the descending aorta by a gamma variate fit.
To express blood flow per unit volume of lung parenchyma, it is assumed that the region of interest (ROI) is composed of air and water (i.e. blood and parenchyma). The disparate densities of these components allow the fraction of each to be calculated using the CT gray scale or HU for any ROI. For example, the water fraction can be calculated by subtracting the CT value of pure air from the mean CT value of an ROI to provide a value reflecting the amount (density) of parenchyma and blood present in the selected region. Comparing this value to the continuum ranging from water (0 HU) to air (1000 HU), allows the percentage of the ROI which is water (blood and parenchyma) to be calculated as follows 17:
Measurement of cardiac output using EBCT is based on the Stewart-Hamilton equation, with iodinated contrast medium in the aorta used as an indicator 16, 18:
Image analysis
Statistical analysis Comparisons between ventilatory and haemodynamic parameters during each intervention and differences in regional perfusion ROIS under the same study conditions were compared using analyses of variance (ANOVA). For comparisons of perfusion distributions (ROIS) under different study conditions, a two-way ANOVA was applied. For comparison of individual perfusion gradients between interventions (ROIM) linear regression analysis was applied, using the Standard Two Stage method 19. For relative perfusion compared with the section mean under normoxic conditions, standard linear regression analysis was applied to group data, and the square of the coefficient of correlation was used to quantify what proportion of flow variability was explained by the independent variable.
All five subjects tolerated the experimental protocol without difficulty or adverse reactions. The results of haemodynamic and ventilatory variables during the scanning protocol are detailed in table 1
Using ROSS, under normoxic conditions a nondependent to dependent gradient in regional perfusion was observed, which was maximal at 50% of the nondependent/dependent distance. Perfusion remained relatively constant in the most dependent regions of the lung (fig. 2
When examining regional perfusion using ROIM, a nondependent/dependent gradient was again detected under both normoxic and hypoxic conditions (fig. 3a
Both analyses revealed that the addition of iNO under hypoxic conditions resulted in an increase in perfusion values throughout the lung section (p<0.01 ROIS) (fig. 2
This study demonstrated a number of important findings. First, that the relative-regional pulmonary perfusion may be quantified in normal human subjects using EBCT, obtaining values of perfusion comparable to those obtained with existing, less clinically applicable, techniques. Secondly, it has been confirmed that a vertical gradient of perfusion exists under resting conditions in the supine human lung. Thirdly, under hypoxic conditions evidence of increased perfusion in nondependent lung regions resulting in a more uniform distribution of pulmonary perfusion was demonstrated. Finally, the addition of iNO during hypoxia led to an increase in perfusion across all regions of the basal lung section, consistent with the reversal of HPV, with redistribution of pulmonary blood flow to the lung bases. Under all conditions, high spatial-resolution analysis confirmed a marked degree of perfusion heterogeneity between anatomically related regions of the lung section.
Despite these positive findings, this study had a number of limitations in terms of experimental method. First, numerous interacting phenomenon are likely to be responsible for regulating regional pulmonary blood flow. Although the use of IPPV enabled accuracy in terms of the administration of gas mixtures and airway pressures to be maintained, the authors were unable to control for the effects of other variables. Thus, hypoxia-induced changes in cardiac output (as was shown here, table 1 The primary aim of this investigation was to establish the nature and extent of changes in regional blood flow in response to hypoxia, without and with the addition of iNO. Previous investigators have used relative estimates of perfusion, either comparing that of one region to that of another or quantifying V'/Q' relationships. Absolute measures of pulmonary perfusion are difficult to obtain using currently available techniques. In experimental animals, such values can be obtained using microspheres, and positron emission tomography has been used in humans, and have shown comparable values to those corrected perfusion data reported here 22, 23. Further, data from the current study are in accordance with estimates of pulmonary perfusion acquired using EBCT in experimental animals 16, 24. EBCT measures of perfusion, both in this and in previous animal studies, have tended to be slightly lower in comparison to values obtained using other techniques, possibly due to the limitations of the technique outlined above and the fact that measurement of tissue perfusion with EBCT is based on microsphere algorithms. Consequently, any loss of indicator from the tissue results in an underestimation of the absolute value of perfusion 15, 25, 26.
The influence of gravity on the distribution of pulmonary perfusion identified here has been explained traditionally through the interaction of alveolar, pulmonary arterial and venous and interstitial pressures 8, 9. Recent studies using high spatial-resolution microsphere techniques have suggested that the branching pattern of the pulmonary vascular tree leads to more heterogeneity of perfusion than could be explained by gravity alone; the so-called fractal hypothesis 10, 11. Using these techniques, gravity was found to account for only 210% of the perfusion heterogeneity in the prone and supine postures in dogs 11, and for Pulmonary vasoconstriction in response to alveolar hypoxia has been shown to occur in all mammalian species including humans 1. Although the magnitude of the response may vary from one individual to another 1, 14, ventilation with FI,O2 0.12 in the current study resulted in a changes in Sa,O2, heart rate and (estimated) cardiac output compatible with previous studies using direct measurements of Ppa 1, 7, 31. Studies using other techniques, performed in both experimental animals and humans, have suggested that under conditions of generalised hypoxia there is a redistribution of blood from dependent to nondependent lung regions 3234. Studies in experimental animals have shown that this redistribution of blood flow is secondary to recruitment of previously unperfused capillaries in these regions, with minimal evidence of capillary dilatation 35. This recruitment phenomenon has been found to correlate strongly with the increased pulmonary artery pressure 36, secondary to arterial vasoconstriction seen under conditions of generalised hypoxia, with other possible variables (changes in left atrial pressure and cardiac output) having a minimal role. It is not immediately obvious how recruitment of a local capillary bed can occur when hypoxia causes pulmonary artery vasoconstriction. However, increased pulmonary artery pressure caused by generalised vasoconstriction tends to reduce the normally existing gravitational gradient of pulmonary perfusion by increasing flow in Zone II conditions and decreasing the amount of lung under Zone I conditions. This recruitment of the capillary bed in nondependent regions is believed to increase the area available for gaseous exchange under conditions of generalised hypoxia 37. In the current investigation, during hypoxaemic conditions there was also evidence of increased perfusion in nondependent lung regions, leading to a more uniform vertical gradient of perfusion. Although this change was small, there are several reasons why changes in regional perfusion may have been under estimated. First, subjects were mechanically ventilated, and the scans were performed during an inspiratory breath-hold manoeuvre. Although the plateau pressures generated during each scan study were low (5.5±0.7, 5.33±0.8, 5.5±0.6 cmH2O), lung inflation above functional residual capacity 8, and the application of positive pressure ventilation 2629, both resulted in a redistribution of blood from nondependent towards dependent regions. Secondly, the configuration of the EBCT scanner results in the dose of radiation to the patient and its scatter and noise distribution being radially asymmetrical, with increased noise to signal ratios in the upper quadrant, which could impair the accuracy of this technique in measuring perfusion in regions within this area, which corresponds to the nondependent regions of the lung slice. Thirdly, radiographic contrast agents, even nonionic media, are known to be mild vasodilators. Certain vasodilator compounds are known to modulate the effects of HPV 14, and in particular, reverse the redistribution observed with hypoxia, there being derecruitment of capillaries in nondependent regions, with blood flow redistributed back towards dependent regions 37. Finally, in experimental models and animal experiments, EBCT measures of perfusion have been shown to increasingly underestimate true perfusion at higher flow rates due to increased washout of contrast. It is possible that with the increase in cardiac output seen under hypoxic conditions in the current study, perfusion estimates underestimated the true increase in perfusion seen in nondependent lung regions. However, previous studies have shown that the increased perfusion seen in these regions is due to capillary recruitment, which correlates poorly with changes in cardiac output or flow 36. The deciding factor in the current experiment would depend on the degree in which the increased perfusion in nondependent regions was dependent on capillary recruitment, which should have no effect or possibly improve perfusion estimates due to reductions in capillary flow rates, versus increased flow through previously perfused capillaries. Such data is not available with this technique. Inhaled nitric oxide has been shown to reverse hypoxic pulmonary vasoconstriction in lambs 5, adult sheep 6, and normal human subjects 7. In the current investigation, following the addition of inhaled nitric oxide under hypoxic conditions, perfusion values increased in all regions of the lung section, consistent with the reversal of hypoxic pulmonary vasoconstriction. However, this was in the setting of an overall decrease in cardiac output. How can this finding be explained? First, was the measure of cardiac output accurate? Cardiac output measurements using electron-beam computed tomography are based on indicator dilution techniques, and have been demonstrated to be less accurate at increasing flow rates 9, 25, with a tendency to over estimate true flow. Such an inaccuracy fails to explain the observed data. Alternatively, conservation of blood flow predicts that if cardiac output were to decrease, then average pulmonary blood flow would also have to decrease. Therefore, the finding that blood flow increased in the basal or caudal lung section in this study may suggest redistribution from another region of the lung. In the supine position other investigators have reported horizontal "isogravity" gravity gradients, with caudal blood flow being less than cranial 38, 39. Under conditions of hypoxia, these gradients are exaggerated 32, with cranial flow increasing relative to caudal flow, suggesting that the caudal vessels are more responsive in terms of hypoxic pulmonary vasoconstriction 40, and possibly therefore, to reversal of this phenomenon. In the current study, only one lung section in the caudal region of the lung was investigated, and therefore this hypothesis cannot be fully confirmed.
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||